Optical tweezers were employed to investigate the effects of small DNA-binding molecules on the low-force (≤ 15 pN) stretching behaviour of single DNA molecules. As the canonical B-DNA helix is not perturbed in this force regime, the effects on DNA elasticity observed upon drug binding provide useful insight into how DNA-binding drugs may alter in vivo processes. In this study, the effects of agents with different DNA binding modes were analysed. DNA force—extension curves were recorded in the presence of netropsin, a purely minor groove-binding antibiotic drug, ethidium bromide, an intercalating fluorescent dye, and berenil, an antiprotozoal drug proposed to exhibit both intercalative and minor groove-binding modes. Applying an approximation of the worm-like chain model, which describes the low-force stretching behaviour, the results were analysed in terms of the DNA contour length and persistence length. From these single molecule studies it was observed that minor groove-binding and intercalating modes of DNA-binding could be distinguished based on changes to DNA elasticity.