1,3-Dimethyl-2-(4-(dimethylamino)phenyl)-2,4-dihydro-1H-benzoimidazole, N-DMBI-H, is widely used as an air-stable n-dopant for organic semiconductors. Here, its reactivity is investigated with a variety of imide- and amide-containing semiconductor molecules that have reduction potentials in the range −0.54 to −1.10 V versus ferrocene. Reaction rates correlate poorly with these potentials. The more reactive of the imides form the corresponding radical anions cleanly, but kinetic isotope studies using N-DMBI-D indicate that the reaction proceeds via an initial hydride- or hydrogen-transfer step. For an amide- and ester-rigidified bis(styryl)benzene derivative the hydride-reduced product is stable under an inert atmosphere and can be observed directly; the radical anion can only be obtained in sub-stoichiometric yield and under certain reaction conditions. On the other hand, (N-DMBI)₂ rapidly reduces all the imides and amides examined to the corresponding radical anions. The implications of these findings for dopant selection and use are discussed.