The highly conserved and essential Plasmodium falciparum reticulocyte-binding protein homolog 5 (PfRH5) has emerged as the leading target for vaccines that seek to protect against the disease-causing blood-stage of malaria. However, the features of the human vaccine-induced antibody response that confer highly potent inhibition of malaria parasite invasion into red blood cells are not well defined. Here we characterize over 200 human IgG monoclonal antibodies induced by the most advanced PfRH5 vaccine. We define the antigenic landscape of this molecule, and establish epitope specificity, antibody association rate and intra-PfRH5 antibody interactions are key determinants of functional anti-parasitic potency. In addition, we identify a germline gene combination that results in an exceptionally potent class of antibody and demonstrate its prophylactic potential to protect against P. falciparum parasite challenge in vivo. This comprehensive dataset provides a framework to guide rational design of next-generation vaccines and prophylactic antibodies to protect against blood-stage malaria.