Fluorescent small molecules are important tools in many aspects of modern biology. A two-stage evaluation process involving fluorescence screening and live-cell imaging was developed to facilitate the identification of new fluorescent probes from extracts housed within the NCI Natural Products Repository. To this end, over 2000 extracts and prefractionated samples were examined, including an extract from the marine crinoid Pterometra venusta. An optically guided evaluation involving stepwise fluorescence screening and live-cell imaging was developed to enable the isolation of fluorescent natural products. These efforts resulted in the isolation of six hydroxyanthraquinone compounds, three of which are new natural products. These purified metabolites were examined for their potential as cellular imaging probes, and they demonstrate that natural product libraries can be a good source of new fluorescent agents.