Onondaga Lake is a hypereutrophic, industrially polluted lake located in Syracuse, NY. High hypolimnetic concentrations of H₂S that develop after anoxia restrict the accumulation of total Fe²⁺ due to the formation of FeS, and may limit Fe-PO₄ interactions. High water column concentrations of Ca²⁺ and high rates of CaCO₃ deposition occur due to inputs of Ca²⁺ from an adjacent soda ash manufacturing facility. Patterns of P concentration and other water chemistry parameters in the lower waters, and results from chemical equilibrium calculations, suggest that Ca-PO₄ minerals may regulate the supply of P from sediments to the water column in Onondaga Lake. These findings have important management implications for Onondaga Lake. First, declines in water column Ca²⁺ concentrations due to reductions in industrial CaCl₂ input may result in conditions of undersaturation with respect to Ca-PO₄ mineral solubility and increases in the release of P from sediments to the water column. Second, introduction of O₂ from hypolimnetic oxygenation, as a lake remediation initiative, may enhance P supply from sediments, because of increased solubility of Ca-PO₄ minerals at lower pH.