Gender differences among active reviewers: an investigation based on Publons

L Zhang, Y Shang, Y Huang, G Sivertsen - Scientometrics, 2022 - Springer
Peer review of scientific manuscripts before publication is essential in scholarly publishing,
and most active researchers hold relationships with a number of journals as both an author …

Peer review and gender bias: A study on 145 scholarly journals

F Squazzoni, G Bravo, M Farjam, A Marusic… - Science …, 2021 - science.org
Scholarly journals are often blamed for a gender gap in publication rates, but it is unclear
whether peer review and editorial processes contribute to it. This article examines gender …

No evidence of any systematic bias against manuscripts by women in the peer review process of 145 scholarly journals

F Squazzoni, G Bravo, P Dondio, M Farjam, A Marusic… - 2020 - air.unimi.it
This article examines gender bias in peer review with complete data on 145 journals in
various fields of research, including about 1.7 million authors and 740,000 referees. We …

How does research productivity relate to gender? Analyzing gender differences for multiple publication dimensions

SJ Mayer, JMK Rathmann - Scientometrics, 2018 - Springer
Measures of research productivity have become widely used for obtaining tenure, third-party
funding, and additional resources from universities. However, previous studies indicate that …

The reviewer in the mirror: examining gendered and ethnicized notions of reciprocity in peer review

B Demarest, G Freeman, CR Sugimoto - Scientometrics, 2014 - Springer
Numerous studies have sought to uncover violations of objectivity and impartiality in peer
review; however the notion of reciprocity has been absent in much of this discussion …

The hurdles of academic publishing from the perspective of journal editors: a case study

MJ Mrowinski, A Fronczak, P Fronczak, O Nedic… - Scientometrics, 2020 - Springer
In this paper, we provide insight into the editorial process as seen from the perspective of
journal editors. We study a dataset obtained from the Journal of the Serbian Chemical …

Understanding the peer review endeavor in scientific publishing

G Zhang, S Xu, Y Sun, C Jiang, X Wang - Journal of Informetrics, 2022 - Elsevier
Peer review plays an essential role in the scholarly publishing life cycle. Using the verified
peer review records of reviewers who use the Publons, we employed review length as a …

[HTML][HTML] Personal attributes of authors and reviewers, social bias and the outcomes of peer review: a case study

R Walker, B Barros, R Conejo, K Neumann… - …, 2015 - ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
Peer review is the" gold standard" for evaluating journal and conference papers, research
proposals, on-going projects and university departments. However, it is widely believed that …

Author-reviewer homophily in peer review

D Murray, K Siler, V Larivière, WM Chan, AM Collings… - BioRxiv, 2018 - biorxiv.org
The fairness of scholarly peer review has been challenged by evidence of disparities in
publication outcomes based on author demographic characteristics. To assess this, we …

Gender bias in journals of gender studies

H Kretschmer, R Kundra, D deB. Beaver… - Scientometrics, 2012 - akjournals.com
The causes of gender bias favoring men in scientific and scholarly systems are complex and
related to overall gender relationships in most of the countries of the world. An as yet …