Deviance and dissent in groups

J Jetten, MJ Hornsey - Annual review of psychology, 2014 - annualreviews.org
Traditionally, group research has focused more on the motivations that make people
conform than on the motivations and conditions underpinning deviance and dissent. This …

Behavioral consequences of intergroup sensitivity

JL Thürmer, SM McCrea - Social and Personality Psychology …, 2023 - Wiley Online Library
Communication of criticism between groups is important to productive societal discourse, but
may serve to inflame conflict. The defensive rejection of intergroup, relative to intragroup …

A hero for the outgroup, a black sheep for the ingroup: Societal perceptions of those who confront discrimination

M Kutlaca, J Becker, H Radke - Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2020 - Elsevier
Confrontation of discrimination can be seen as a form of morally courageous behavior,
however those who engage in it presumably risk societal backlash. In three experiments, we …

Disentangling the intergroup sensitivity effect: Defending the ingroup or enforcing general norms?

JL Thürmer, SM McCrea - European Journal of Social …, 2021 - Wiley Online Library
Group members reject threatening outgroup criticism compared to the same criticism from
the ingroup (intergroup sensitivity effect [ISE]). Uninvolved bystanders (ie, members of third …

Tough love: The normative conflict model and a goal system approach to dissent decisions

DJ Packer, CTH Miners - Social and Personality Psychology …, 2014 - Wiley Online Library
Most rebels have a cause, and the expression of internal criticism and dissent is vital for
healthy civic and collective functioning. Here, we review the normative conflict model (NCM) …

When group members dissent: A direct comparison of the black sheep and intergroup sensitivity effects

AK Reiman, TC Killoran - Journal of Experimental Social Psychology, 2023 - Elsevier
How do people react to opinion conflict occurring within an ingroup? Whereas some work
suggests that dissenting ingroup members evoke more negativity than equivalently …

Beyond motivated reasoning: Hostile reactions to critical comments from the outgroup.

JL Thürmer, SM McCrea - Motivation Science, 2018 - psycnet.apa.org
People are motivated to process threatening information in a defensive manner. For
instance, in self-reports, group members consistently reject threatening outgroup criticism …

Intergroup sensitivity in a divided society: Calls for unity and reconciliatory behavior during the 2020 US presidential election

JL Thürmer, SM McCrea - Group Processes & Intergroup …, 2024 - journals.sagepub.com
The United States is highly divided along party lines, and this partisan divide has a
tremendous impact on social relationships and even health-related behavior. Although …

Effect of threat and social identity on reactions to ingroup criticism: Defensiveness, openness, and a remedy

L Adelman, N Dasgupta - Personality and Social Psychology …, 2019 - journals.sagepub.com
Openness to criticism and dissenting opinions is enormously important to group decision-
making. Past research has found that people are more persuaded by criticism of their group …

Motivated collective defensiveness: Group members prioritize counterarguing out-group criticism over getting their work done

JL Thürmer, SM McCrea… - … and Personality Science, 2019 - journals.sagepub.com
Group members defensively reject out-group criticism in self-reports because they perceive
it as more threatening than the same criticism from the in-group (intergroup sensitivity effect) …