Can a paid model for peer review be sustainable when the author can decide whether to pay or not?

JA García, R Rodriguez-Sánchez, J Fdez-Valdivia - Scientometrics, 2022 - Springer
Given how hard it is to recruit good reviewers who are aligned with authors in their functions,
journal editors could consider the use of better incentives, such as paying reviewers for their …

Is peer review duration shorter for attractive manuscripts?

G Zhang, F Shang, L Wang, W Xie… - Journal of …, 2023 - journals.sagepub.com
Authors often ask how long the peer review process takes. Peer review duration has
attracted much attention in academia in recent years. Existing research focuses primarily on …

The cross-subsidy and buy-one-give-one models of compensated peer review: A comparative study for mission-driven journals

JA García, RM Rodriguez-Sánchez… - Journal of …, 2024 - journals.sagepub.com
A financial compensation model could incentivise peer reviewers to provide the optimal
amount of effort by rewarding them for their quality reports. Therefore, in this article, we …

Review Ecosystems to access Educational XR Experiences: a Scoping Review

S Bangay, A Cardilini, S McKenzie, M Nicholas… - arXiv preprint arXiv …, 2024 - arxiv.org
Educators, developers, and other stakeholders face challenges when creating, adapting,
and utilizing virtual and augmented reality (XR) experiences for teaching curriculum topics …

[PDF][PDF] Роль и значимость рецензирования в отечественной и иностранной научной периодике в информационно-библиотечной области: сравнительный …

ВН Гуреев, НА Мазов - Научный редактор и издатель, 2021 - researchgate.net
В статье обобщен опыт работы авторов в качестве рецензентов на выборке более чем
ста рукописей из 12 российских и зарубежных научных журналов по информационно …

The interplay between the reviewer's incentives and the journal's quality standard

JA Garcia, R Rodriguez-Sánchez, J Fdez-Valdivia - Scientometrics, 2021 - Springer
In this paper, we study the reviewer's compensation problem in the presence of quality
standard considerations. We examine a typical scenario in which a journal has to match the …

Cultural distance, gender and praise in peer review

G Zhang, L Wang, X Wang - Accountability in Research, 2024 - Taylor & Francis
Background: Understanding review comments holds significant importance within the realm
of scientific discourse. This study aims to conduct an empirical analysis of factors associated …

No reward without responsibility: Focus on peer review reports

JAT da Silva, T Daly - Ethics, Medicine and Public Health, 2025 - Elsevier
Trust in the quality of scholarly publishing is vital for the integrity of science and medicine in
society. An ongoing debate about peer review has divided its participants into those who …

The editor-manuscript game

JA García, R Rodriguez-Sánchez, J Fdez-Valdivia - Scientometrics, 2021 - Springer
Scientific journals receive an increasing number of submissions and many of them will be
desk rejected without receiving detailed feedback from reviewers. In fact, the number of desk …

Quality censoring in peer review

JA Garcia, R Rodriguez-Sánchez, J Fdez-Valdivia - Scientometrics, 2021 - Springer
In a typical scenario in which a peer-reviewed journal has to match the uncertain
manuscript's quality with its quality standard, quality improvement is restricted by the …