Judicial deference at work: some reflections on Chan Kin Sum and Kong Yun Ming

C Chan - Hong Kong LJ, 2010 - HeinOnline
" Due deference"-the giving of appropriate weight to the government's judgment in the
court's reasoning-is a tool that courts use to maintain the separation of powers in …

Principles for judicial deference

R Clayton - Judicial Review, 2006 - Taylor & Francis
1. Deference involves the principle that the courts (out of respect for the legislature or
executive) will decline to make their own independent judgment on a particular issue. The …

The paradox of judicial deference

G Davidov - National Journal of Constitutional Law, 2001 - papers.ssrn.com
This article analyses the Canadian constitutional case-law in which the Supreme Court uses
the doctrine of deference, and considers the justifications for this doctrine. The two main …

Rights, proportionality and deference: a study of post-handover judgments in Hong Kong

C Chan - Hong Kong LJ, 2018 - HeinOnline
Around the world, it is common for courts to defer to executive or legislative authorities in
adjudicating human rights issues, on the ground that the latter possess more expertise or …

Proportionality and the separation of powers in Constitutional Review: examining the role of judicial deference

C Henckels - Federal Law Review, 2017 - journals.sagepub.com
The High Court's tentative moves toward adopting structured proportionality as a method of
constitutional review have been hampered by concerns about the separation of powers. This …

Deference: is it useful outside Canada?: the constitutional context

DJ Mullan - Acta Juridica, 2006 - journals.co.za
Judicial deference to the decisions and actions of statutory and prerogative authorities is a
key principle of Canadian judicial review law. In its current incarnation, it frequently requires …

Deference to the administration in judicial review: Comparative perspectives

G Zhu - General Reports of the XXth General Congress of the …, 2021 - Springer
Judicial deference to the administration is a concept and legal practice that is present to a
greater or lesser degree in every constitutional system. The analysis of the national reports …

The darkest domain: Deference, judicial review, and the Bill of Rights

DJ Solove - Iowa L. Rev., 1998 - HeinOnline
After Japan bombed Pearl Harbor, the United States government initiated a series of policies
to restrict the freedom of over 100,000 American citizens of Japanese ancestry living on the …

Deference, defiance, and doctrine: defining the limits of judicial review

TRS Allan - University of Toronto Law Journal, 2010 - utpjournals.press
While a court must respect the sphere of decision-making autonomy properly enjoyed by a
public authority, a general doctrine of deference is unlikely to furnish a useful means of …

Deference and the Separation of Powers: An Assessment of the Court's Constitutional and Institutional Competences

C Chan - Hong Kong LJ, 2011 - HeinOnline
One view among the judiciary in Hong Kong is that courts should defer to the government's
position in adjudicating the constitutionality of policies, because courts are institutionally and …